fostering the humanistic practice of medicine publishing personal accounts of illness and healing encouraging health care advocacy

Search
Close this search box.

fostering the humanistic practice of medicine publishing personal accounts of illness and healing encouraging health care advocacy

Search
Close this search box.
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. New Voices
  4. /
  5. Code Switching: Gravel Against...

Code Switching: Gravel Against Stone

Editor’s Note: This piece was awarded an honorable mention in the Pulse writing contest, “On Being Different.”

As a medical student, I have a habit of lowering my voice an extra octave when I speak with patients, preceptors or even my own primary-care physician. I like to imagine my voice as gravel grinding against stone, my raspy “whiskey voice” melting away any hint of my queer identity.

In these moments, I’m keenly aware of the way I walk and stand, the firmness of my handshake and the content of the small talk I make. There are no lights, no curtains or stage, but I am nonetheless performing.

I also have a habit of over-enunciating words that begin with R, F, Th, V and Z, such as radial, fistula and thalassemia–words with phonetics not included in my native Korean language. When speaking these words, I imagine my lips performing acrobatics on gently sloping hills made of velvet. I visualize the swoops and dives required to roll the Rs (to make them sound different from Ls) and the softening of the edges in saying Vs (to make them sound different from Bs).

Growing up in the suburbs of Georgia as a queer East Asian student who was still mastering English as a second language, I tried everything within my power to fit in. Maybe you are familiar with this repertoire: immigrant children working to melt away accents and to culturally assimilate into white, Anglo-Saxon, suburban America; queer men deepening their voices when they enter barbershops. Fretting over “feminine” high tones and “proper” pronunciations is common among queer men and ethnic-minority populations in this country.

There’s not much that I can do about my appearance, the number of melanocytes painting my skin; I am already different at first glance. My voice, however, can be controlled. When I was growing up, to be different was to be marked as “other,” so I learned to command the lilt and rhythms of my speech to fit the mold.

After achieving the coveted native fluency in English and growing more comfortable with being a queer cis-male, I’d hoped that I would outgrow my reservations about projecting my natural voice. In clinical or medical-education settings, however, I’ve found myself carrying the same anxieties, feeling the same knot in the pit of my stomach that I’d felt in childhood.

In probing into why I feel this way, I’ve come up with two main reasons.

One, the emotional labor of being a medical student, and constantly being evaluated, has simply repackaged my childhood desire to fit in. Now I desire to be evaluated as a competent medical student and future physician.

But what exactly makes a competent physician? This leads to reason two: I have yet to meet a physician like me—queer and East Asian. I am, therefore, reflexively using straight white masculinity as a benchmark for medical professionalism. I lower my voice and over-enunciate certain consonants because, like many medical students, I want to be evaluated favorably. I am still carrying the heavy weight of my childhood notion that to be different is to be singled out as “other”—and I fear that it may impact the outcome of my medical education.

These vocal habits are a form of self-preservation. But when I reflect on my childhood, and my lack of exposure to queer-physician role models, I fear that I will be perpetuating the problem.

I remember being hesitant, as a teen, to discuss queer sexual health with my primary-care provider. Unfortunately, my public high-school curriculum advocated for abstinence and taught sexual health only within the framework of heterosexual relationships. How I wished, even at that age, to have a physician who was more like me; someone who could help me to navigate queer interpersonal relationships, affection, body image and the like.

Now, despite knowing what it’s like not to have visibly queer physician role models, I still find myself trying hard to perform my existence as the most stereotypically masculine version of myself.

I believe that being different as a queer physician of color will only be a boon to my future clinical practice. My cultural sensitivity to my future patients, and our shared lived experiences, will undoubtedly help to build rapport. However, to stand in my truth, I recognize that I have much internal work to do.

In putting these thoughts into words, I hope to take the first of many steps toward embracing the differences that make me valuable as a clinician and as a person.

Andrew C. is a medical student at the University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry. When he is not busy being a student and catching up on life chores, he tries to make time to read for pleasure. “I have loved reading and writing from an early age, as they helped me to better express my thoughts when I was first learning English. I hope to continue expanding my skills in both narrative prose and scientific writing as I begin my medical career.”

Comments

11 thoughts on “Code Switching: Gravel Against Stone”

  1. Hi Andrew, I just want to speak up in support — I’m Asian too, and although cishet, an ally of LGBTQ folk. I’ve seen queer residents and queer attendings able to be out, and really pray you’ll find acceptance and naturalness where you end up for training and for practice. I think after medical school you’ll start to feel more confidence in “bringing your whole self to work.”

  2. I am so sorry for all that you have suffered.

    But please let me make a suggestion: you truly
    need to see a gay psychiatrist who speciaizes in
    helping patients like you.
    You are not alone–far from it.
    There a great many Gays of various races in the U.S.
    I truly hope that you have moved to a part of the U.S.
    with a diverse population where you meet many folks
    like you.
    I am in NYC. Here, you would find a diverse and far
    more tolerant population.

  3. Grateful to you for writing this piece and giving voice to these aspects of the inquietudes that fill medical education and training, particularly as you have experienced them. From a former URSMD student to another, thank you for your courage, honesty, and willingness to share a bit of yourself. I hope you keep writing through the many more years that medicine will be lucky to have you!

  4. Thank you for your candid essay. I wish you well as you move forward in your life. Please do not lose yourself in your desire to fit in. And please continue to find time to read and write!

  5. This is so beautifully written and your insight is so powerful. Wishing you much success in your journey. Your empathy shines through, and will carry you.

  6. Andrew, although I am straight and white, I can imagine how terribly painful it has been to mask your true self as a queer Asian man, now in the process of becoming a doctor. Having to conform to a notion of masculinity, whatever that means, must have been and continue to be an extra pressure to withstand in the medical world. In writing this, your “coming out” and honestly describing how hard it’s been, is a gift to yourself and to all who read it. Thank you and enjoy the beauty of a genuine queer life .

  7. Thank you for the thoughtful narration of your journey, Andrew. It is another flavor of the “impostor syndrome” that we all confront to varying degrees, with an added challenge. I hope you discover that it reflects more on your personal acceptance (and love) of yourself than the actual reactions of patients and colleagues, and that, as you progress in your career, you are able to express yourself more freely. Caring and competence will win your future patients’ hearts!

  8. You have such value and worth to your present peers and future patients. Keep writing. Keep fighting– for yourself, and for those you will someday serve. You all deserve the most authentic version of you, and you’re doing the hard work to keep getting there.
    Feel free to reply if you’re interested in getting in touch with a colleague who may have some shared experiences with you (I’m thinking in particular of a beloved colleague of mine who is queer, East Asian, and was a fellow graduate of URSMD).
    U of R is lucky to have you.

  9. I can identify with your story. I’m not queer, but I clearly remember a med school lecture, or maybe it was a comment, or maybe it was just a comment to me, about voice pitch and level in talking to patients. And I definitely remember intentionally lowering the pitch of my 20 some year old voice so that my patients would be able to listen, to hear, a more pleasant, more mellow speaker. I think it was useful and helpful information, and I still pay attention to the “sound” of my words as well as my advice. Incidentally, I always sang soprano in high school, but have now, as a mature older clinician, become a tenor in our choir!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *