Finding a Common Chord

“I long, as does every human being, to be at home wherever I find myself.” — Maya Angelou

Before starting my dive into medicine, almost four years ago, I was an avid violinist, pianist, disc golfer and novice chef. Each of these activities felt comfortable and familiar–like “home.” But when I began medical school, I somewhat wistfully set them aside to focus on becoming a doctor.

If I can get through this grueling stage of my life, maybe things will get better, I told myself.

As my medical studies progressed, my violin collected dust in a corner of my living room. Then, during one of my third-year clinical clerkships, I met Ms. Winston.

A frail, elderly woman with advanced dementia, she’d been hospitalized after her caregiver, a nurse named Shirley, brought her in with fever and confusion.

As Shirley recounted Ms. Winston’s medical history, Ms. Winston sat there barely moving, a glassy look in her eyes. She only spoke once, when asked how she was doing: “I’m fine.”

Shirley, by contrast, was relentlessly energetic: She asked if the antibiotics we’d prescribed were appropriate, and after Ms. Winston suffered a choking episode she wanted to review Ms. Winston’s chest X-rays herself.

As challenging as I found it to respond to Shirley’s concerns, I found it even more frustrating to build a relationship with Ms. Winston. When I tried to talk with her, she would simply give me that silent, glassy stare. My most vociferous questions elicited only an occasional soft “yes” or “no.” I wanted to be a good provider and check in on her throughout the day, but the thought of yet another failed conversation brought up dread and apprehension.

After two days of this, I was desperate for some way to connect with Ms. Winston. Then things took an unexpected turn.

Approaching her room the next morning, I heard Bach’s Double Violin Concerto wafting from her radio. I know this piece well, having played it several times in my previous life.

As I walked in, I mentally scrapped my medical-student playbook.

“Do you like classical music?” I asked Ms. Winston.

Her eyes lit up.

“Yes!” she said with a smile, looking straight at me.

“She loves the radio,” Shirley chimed in. “She was a violinist and pianist for forty years.”

“What a coincidence!” I said. “I play those instruments too!”

We talked about her favorite composers and pieces. She reminisced about playing piano for church and was excited to hear that I’d started violin at age four.

If this had been our first encounter, I’d never have guessed that she had dementia. In my mind, she shifted from being a patient to being a musician, an artist and a peer. I was enjoying the conversation so much, I almost forgot to do her exam.

Later on, when I reported this to my medical team during rounds, they expressed surprise at my being a violinist, and even more surprise at Ms. Winston’s transformation.

“Wouldn’t it be cool if you brought your violin and played for her?” my attending exclaimed. We all chuckled.

Rounds went by without any further mention of music. But before I left the wards, my intern stopped me.

“The attending texted me to ask if you can bring in your violin tomorrow,” she said.

I was shocked, even terrified: Are we allowed to do that?

I’d never seen a provider play music for a patient. Questions flooded my mind: Was it a mistake to mention my conversation with Ms. Winston? Will I embarrass myself in front of everyone?

I hadn’t played the violin for almost two years. My evening plans had involved writing up a history-and-physical note, not revisiting my former pastimes. Still, I went ahead and dusted off my violin.

After playing through a few scales, arpeggios and pieces, I realized that I’d retained some of the easier pieces in my muscle memory. Sure, my fingers slipped a bit on the higher pitches; but I felt confident that I could play the music. More importantly, I didn’t want to miss a chance to do something meaningful for Ms. Winston.

Supposedly, dementia patients store music in their long-term memory, I thought. Wouldn’t it be great if I could help her add some new musical memories?

The next morning, my team gathered expectantly at Ms. Winston’s bed. Tuning the violin, I felt hopeful that she would enjoy the music that I’d planned.

“Do you want to hear something fast and lively, or slow and beautiful?” I asked her.

She chose the latter. I began playing “Méditation” from the opera Thaïs by Massenet–a lyrical, romantic piece that expresses a courtesan’s emotions at leaving her lavish life for one of humility.

As I played the first notes, Ms. Winston closed her eyes and smiled. The warm, tranquil tones flowed on, and she gently swayed in time, enjoying the music. She looked like Ms. Winston, not just another patient with dementia.

For me, hearing the strings of my violin again brought back nostalgic memories: feeling chills down my spine while playing Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony, and my brother’s and my playful duels with our bows. Playing violin for Ms. Winston reminded me of an identity–a home–I hadn’t visited in a very long time. It was humbling to realize how much of myself I’d set aside in committing myself to medicine.

I’ll never forget Ms. Winston’s simple “Thank you” and smile. Seeing my team’s tears of joy and hearing the applause of friends and staff who’d snuck in mid-performance, I felt touched and grateful.

I hope Ms. Winston found home in that performance, because I definitely did. If I hadn’t shared the music with her, I don’t think I’d ever have seen through her diagnoses to the person–the artist–that she is.

Ironically, playing music worked the same alchemy in me: I reconnected with a vital part of myself and realized how important it is that I hold onto it amid this arduous professional training.

Although some facets of my identity have receded for now, I still cherish them. Now, thanks to Ms. Winston, I know that they’re still there–waiting for me to reclaim them when the time is right.

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Jimmy Chen is a fourth-year medical student at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland. “I discovered writing during my undergraduate medical training. When I felt burnt out or stressed out from patient care, I found writing therapeutic: It helped me to find empathy when I was feeling frustrated, taught me always to be in reflection and constantly reminded me of the humanistic side of medicine when the wards were feeling sterile. I would especially like to thank Drs. Rebecca Harrison and Katie Drago for their continued support of my musical aspirations in patient care.”

Comments

14 thoughts on “Finding a Common Chord”

  1. Marianne Lonsdale

    Thanks for writing this – so much here – the good writing and how much discovery of what’s important and what works for your patient, for you, for your fellow students and teachers. Hoping the air clears soon In Portland.

  2. There will never be a “right time” – life only gets more complicated. Carpe diem! Keep on doing the things that are important to you.

  3. Love this story and connecting to who the person is beyond a Dx. True Tell Me More.
    Grateful to read and thank you for writing and sharing. Very special. Most impt. You influenced the entire clinical team too.

  4. In the Healer’s Art course, being taught in over 70 medical schools internationally, the first session deals with meaning, wholeness and self-care. It explores, in an exercise, the part of the student’s life which may be forgotten or left behind as he/she enters the halls of academia. In this case the importance of music. In my first year teaching the course one of the students had also put the violin aside, while another stated in our small group portion, “I want to take a walk in the park, but all my classmates are in the library studying! What do I do?” As Dr. Rachel Naomi Remen, founder of the course, would tell the students in her introduction, “Who you are is as important as what you learn here in medical school.” Keep playing, Jimmy!

  5. A friend volunteered in a program bringing older, familiar music to dementia patients and it made a difference in their ability to relate. I was delighted to hear your story since it fits with what scattered people are doing but it still hasn’t gone mainstream in dementia programs. Thank goodness you related to her that way and brought her back for a little while.

  6. Ever try the tonic of asking the patient to bring her instrument into clinic? A few lines of melody can awaken resonance and harmony. A few minutes of pathos or joy shared by patient, clinican and staff can empower humanity and healing.

  7. Thanks so much for this beautiful essay! I am a firm believer in combining music and medicine – while caring for patients and in our own lives. I believe we are better physicians when we express ourselves fully – including our artistic sides. Please keep playing – it will help maintain balance in your own life, in addition to the impact it can have on patients like Ms Winston.

    1. Henry Schneiderman

      Wonderful story. I stopped painting for many years during my long medical career. You have reminded me that now in retirement I need to reclaim this arena. And I share Dr Wager’s advice, supportively urging you to keep playing your music. Bravo!

  8. This essay was especially meaningful for me. My dad — an amazing musician — had Alzheimer’s, and in the last months and days of his life, music was the touchstone that was most meaningful to him. Thank you for the beautifully expressive “composition.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Stories

Popular Tags
addiction (11) alcohol addiction (3) allergies (2) anatomy lab (7) bedside manner (21) bigotry (3) breast cancer (13) cancer (116) caregiver stories (32) caregiving (33) chemotherapy (13) child abuse (1) childbirth (10) chronic illness (10) complementary therapies (1) confidentiality (2) connecting with patients (12) coping with death (29) coping with illness (42) coping with patient death (12) cross-cultural health care (6) cultural competence (33) death and dying (114) death of a parent (5) dementia (22) depression (14) diabetes (6) disability (10) doctor-patient communication (81) doctor-patient relationship (75) doctor as patient (35) doctor poems (25) doctor stories (127) drug addiction (9) end of life (102) end of life decision making (28) faith (3) family medicine (8) frustration with healthcare system (15) genetic disorders (3) geriatrics (46) getting the news (11) healing (3) health care policy (22) health care politics (5) health insurance (19) HIV (11) hospital (8) humor (17) ill parent (47) immigration (6) inequality (11) international health (18) labor and delivery (8) leukemia (2) medical errors (7) medical student stories (96) medical training (79) medicine (1) memorable patients (47) mental health (23) mental health professional stories (6) mental illness (11) military medicine (3) miracles (10) miscarriage (7) mistakes (11) neuroscience (2) nurse poems (19) nurse stories (35) nursing (19) ob/gyn (15) palliative care (10) parent stories (22) Parkinson's disease (2) patient-centered care (5) patient poems (8) patient stories (35) pediatrics (37) personal remembrance (10) physician assistant stories (2) poems/poetry (149) pregnancy (29) PTSD (4) race (13) realizing human mortality (9) resident stories (39) role modeling (5) self care (3) social determinants of health (15) social issues (22) social worker stories (4) spirituality (4) stress and burnout (23) suicide (5) surgery (14) thanksgiving (1) the bad doctor (9) visuals (170) war veteran (5)
Scroll to Top