fostering the humanistic practice of medicine publishing personal accounts of illness and healing encouraging health care advocacy

Search
Close this search box.

fostering the humanistic practice of medicine publishing personal accounts of illness and healing encouraging health care advocacy

Search
Close this search box.
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Stories
  4. /
  5. Don’t Ever Let Them...

Don’t Ever Let Them Break You

Editor’s Note: This piece was awarded an honorable mention in the Pulse writing contest, “On Being Different.”

I was a woman in medical school before there were more women students than men—back when women were expected to be more masculine than the men if they wanted to succeed as doctors, back when the idea that we could report our medical-school professors for sexual harassment was just a twinkle in the eye of someone braver and less conflict-avoidant than I was.

“Suck me good, Lissa. Suck me hard, Lissa,” my male general-surgery professor jeered day after day, leering at me unapologetically in front of the whole OR team and grabbing my butt whenever we weren’t scrubbed in, while relegating me to the lowest-ranking job on the surgery team, the holder of the suction catheter.

I sucked good and hard to keep that surgical field bloodless—but I never told anyone at the university about my hot tears of rage at the injustice that seared my insides during those years of relentless sexual harassment.

I also never told anyone at the prestigious university where I did my ob/gyn residency how my heart broke on the night when, as the senior resident, I delivered four dead babies in one shift.

But my broken heart was obvious to the coldhearted male professor responsible for overseeing me—the one who pushed through the door to follow me into the women’s locker room after the nurse who’d wept with me all night came to tell me that the fourth baby had died during emergency surgery for an undiagnosed congenital cardiac anomaly.

When the other three babies had died, I had wrapped them in the pastel baby blankets that the women’s auxiliary knitted for the babies who didn’t survive birth. I had crawled into the blood- and amniotic-fluid-soaked beds to hold the babies with their sobbing mothers, letting my own tears and snot mix with all the other body fluids as doctor and mother bonded and comforted one another in our shared womanness.

By the time the fourth baby died, it was 4:00 am, and I was running down the hall to answer the next 911 page when I felt gut-punched by the news that the baby had not survived surgery at the Children’s Hospital next door, where the baby had been transferred after I’d delivered that baby blue.

The fourth baby’s mother had already been moved to the postpartum floor. They wanted me to go ask her consent for an autopsy. I tried to contain the brimming sadness inside my professionalism, so that I could meet the demands of what my supervising male professor expected of me.

But I had not been hardened like he was, yet. Even the long blue coat I wore that night failed to button up my empathy for the women who would not take home babies. (The residents wore blue coats instead of white, an attempt to make us look superior to the lab techs, who also wore long white coats, but inferior to the attending physicians, who wore grey; like Dr. Seuss’s Star-Belly Sneeches, they were always trying to one-up each other.)

No matter how tightly I held my arms around myself and squeezed my eyes to shutter my streaming tears, I couldn’t manage to hold it together, so I raced to the locker room and tried to secure the door behind me, hoping to hide in a stall, undetected.

I failed to go unnoticed. My supervising attending screamed loud enough to arouse concern in the laboring women.

“Buck up, Rankin! You’ll never amount to anything in this profession if you can’t stop feeling so goddamn much!”

I pitied him in that moment for his cruelty and coldness, his dehumanized detachment from the suffering of our patients, his contempt for the humanity of his resident, and the tragedy of what happens to doctors whose hearts close so that they can buck up the way he wanted me to.

I felt sorry for myself, too, as I crumpled to the floor, just in time to see two of the elder midwives escort my attending out of the women’s locker room as if they were heaving a smelly fish overboard, slamming the door behind him, locking him out from the inside and shouting through the door at him.

“Stop punishing Lissa for being a better doctor than you are!” one of the midwives hollered.

“What ever happened to your empathy?” the other one asked.

After securing the perimeter, they scooped me up, cradling me between their matching bosoms and rocking me like I was one of those babies we had just lost. They cooed and hummed until my breathing slowed down and my nerves settled and my tears could finally fall without feeling like there was something wrong with me for feeling so goddamn much.

One of them whispered, “This is how good healers are supposed to react when we lose our patients. Don’t ever let them break you, Lissa.”

I thought if I sucked it up good enough, sucked it up hard enough, I would finally become enough of a man to be a good enough doctor for women. But my path was different.

When I was a thirty-six-year-old mother having my own baby, I realized that I had sucked it up enough. I watched my baby suckling on my own breast, feeling a wave of relief that my baby didn’t wind up wrapped in pink, blue and yellow acrylic yarn before being transported to the morgue.

When I retired from the profession at thirty-seven, because no amount of medical experience could turn me into enough of a man to freeze my heart and stop my feelings, I realized that the very things that made me a good doctor and mother were the qualities that made some think I was never going to amount to anything, because I just feel too goddamn much.

After suffering under the weight of the moral injury that nearly crushed me during my pregnancy, after losing my physician father two weeks after giving birth to my baby, after realizing that I had been pressured as a doctor to suppress most of the qualities we typically associate with femininity—compassion, vulnerability, emotional intelligence, intuition, collaboration, empathy, co-regulating touch, nurturing, intimacy—I submitted my resignation to the male medical director of my hospital.

“What a waste,” he said. “We have to train two women to equal one man in medicine.”

I’ve always felt sorry for the men who’ve had to suppress the more traditionally feminine qualities that the medical system dismisses as “unprofessional.” Boys aren’t born lacking empathy or compassion or feeling fearful of nurturing touch when someone is wounded or grieving or suffering. I can only imagine how much they have to bully their own tender parts in order to put on a stoic face when parents are losing their babies or fathers are losing their wives in childbirth.

For the rest of my career and beyond, I’ve taken all of the more feminine qualities that made me different and poured them out for other female, male, trans and nonbinary healthcare providers who identify with those qualities, offering trauma healing to heal the healers.

When we tell our stories, we never say “Suck me good” or “Suck it up.” Instead, we cheerlead the compassion, vulnerability, nurturing and empathy in each other—and, like those midwives did with me, we coo, “Don’t ever let them break you.”

Lissa Rankin, a retired ob/gyn physician, founded the Whole Health Medicine Institute in 2013 to support healthcare providers, offering recovery from the PTSD many physicians experience as a result of becoming doctors. She has published seven books since retiring and founded Heal At Last, a nonprofit that brings people in recovery from illness, injury or trauma together in circles of healing, spirituality and the arts. She has given four TEDx talks, starred in two National Public Television programs and recently taught a PTSD recovery program at Esalen Institute for frontline COVID healthcare providers. Her website is lissarankin.com. “I continue to support those still on the front lines from the safe distance of my Northern California home, where I live with my daughter, my dog, my housemate April and my partner Jeffrey Rediger, also a physician.”

Comments

21 thoughts on “Don’t Ever Let Them Break You”

  1. Lissa,.for posting your story. I wish I had someone like you as my resident, as my training, as a male, was to ‘buck up’, and the never say “I’m sorry”. 13 years into my practice I was able to take a one year sabbatical to study “Family Systems”. How I wish that had been a part of my ‘Family Medicine’ training. I would have been better able to help and help support my patients the previous 13 years. But later in my 23 years as an associate professor, i found most students did not want to learn about ‘soft medicine’.

  2. David J Nieuwkoop

    Lissa: Thank you so much for telling your story of compassion and courage. It’s one that certainly needs to be told and most importantly, heard by all – especially those of us in the healthcare field.

  3. I am so very sorry for your experiences in residency. My training was Internal Medicine though I was eventually Boarded in Urgent Care. This so did touch my heart…..even though I did not suffer that level of abuse (1985-1990) I had my share.

    My 12 year old daughter and her best friend were abducted at gunpoint by a pedophile. Gone for the week of Christmas 1985. When we got the back the nurses at the hospital were awesome. Wish I could say the same of the Docs. What a nightmare and a way to learn what NOT to do.

  4. I cannot believe what you had to endure! I started medical school in 1970 and though there were fewer women then men, and the same number of women each year, even in retrospect I do not feel that I was discriminated against as a medical student, resident, chief resident and in 1978 the first woman pulmonary fellow. Perhaps it was because you were a surgeon. I recall women surgeons having to be really “tough” even while pregnant. Working until they delivered their babies and a surgical attending rounding in the ER with her baby on her hip.

  5. Hi everyone- I’m so touched by all your comments. Your empathy is a real balm on my heart as I revisit those memories in therapy and give myself the compassion I so often needed and found it hard to find in my medical training. I’ll never forget those wonderful midwives. My memory of their words is why I ultimately left. I felt way too close to breaking and it didn’t feel worth it. I’m sorry to hear so many of you all went through similar abuses and didn’t feel safe to cry when horrible things happen to our patients. I did have one experience a few years later after a huge team was up all night trying to save a mother and fetus who had been shot in the belly. Both mother and baby died and we all wept afterwards- the cardiothoracic team, the NICU team, the OB team. Someone called the chaplain and took our pagers so we could have a moment of silence to allow for what had just happened. It was so comforting- so much better than the night of four dead babies.

  6. Martina Nicholson MD

    Thank you for the courage to write this, unflinchingly. Thank you for the open-heartedness you continue to offer, to heal wounded and traumatized people, using every tool and resource you can find. Your bravery, even in the work of trying to discover what healing methods there are in unconventional healers and shamans, is amazing and pathfinding. You are a stellar writer, researcher and physician, and your soul is grand and majestic, and whole. It was not a waste to train you. It was a gift to humanity, in a much broader way than that narrow-minded and diseased person will ever know. We can heal, we can grow, we can move with joy into a future where the healers are not crippled by bullies and madmen. THANK YOU.

    1. Thank you for your steadfast support, dear sister. I remember telling this story in our physician circle for the first time 15 years ago. You all were so kind to me. I’ll never forget sitting in a circle of doctors who wished me well for the first time. We are so lucky to have each other and Rachel.

  7. I’ll never forget the evening I had dinner with five other women from my IM residency and we discovered we had all cried in the hospital and we all thought we were the only ones. And my residency was humane and supportive of women (at least for the 1980s). What a waste to beat us down and drive us out.

  8. Many years ago, I had a terrific woman internist for about 10 years (she retired). She had gone through a very distinguished, very tough medical program at a major university. At a lecture one day, the professor asked a question; several hands went up, including hers. One after another, the male students were called on, only to give the wrong answer. Finally, as she was the only one left, the professor called on her. She had the correct answer. The professor’s comment: “No woman should know that answer.” I’ll never know where she got that strength and determination. All I know is that she gave me the most thorough, thoughtful, kind care, attending not only to my physical health but to my emotional state (pretty shaky in my adolescence).

  9. Please believe Lissa. I am appalled by her pseudo professor yet why? Some men continue to abase women to this day. Progress is being made, but like Christmas some just give up believing. Thank goodness Lissa walked and was able to create her own very fulfilling life. I love her fortitude, stamina and determination. She is the role model more women need.

    Thank you, Lissa.

  10. Henry Schneiderman

    This is so important and so well written, full of pain from the malice of the perpetrators, but also full of insight and warmth and generosity. As a Palliative Care physician and as a human being, I have so often seen and said that compassion and empathy are not the province of one gender, and when we see their antithesis in men, one sadly reflects with the lyrics, “They’ve got to be carefully taught”. We need just enough distancing from our patients’ tragedies to be able to do the work; and plenty enough identification and empathy to do it well and humanely as you have. I mourn that you were absented from direct clinical care even while celebrating all you have created and given

  11. Your treatment as a medical student and resident was dreadful. I hope you know how strong you were to just survive and to keep your compassion for others afloat
    .I do think medicine is changing When I was an FNP working with family practice residents, I talked with one of their faculty, who was reading nursing articles about teaching “caring” to nursing students. He explained that caring was now a topic included in the family residency program. A hopeful sign!

  12. Dear Lissa,
    Thankyou for sharing what you went through. I’m touched by what the midwives did to help you. That kind of woman strength I saw in the certified nurse midwives I met in Ann Arbor in the mid 1980’s led me to become one. I practiced midwifery for 10 years then went on to other aspects of a 40 year career as a clinician, academic, and IT project manager. Now retired, I write. In my recently published book (A Monarch in Winter: Biography of a Butterfly) I describe evolutionary parallels between newborns and newly emergent butterflies. I had my share of challenging colleagues, too. What doesn’t break us gives us writing material. Thank you for your career of compassionate service.

  13. Brava, Lissa! You have opened, ( along with Pulse), a Pandora’s box that has desperately needed opening… to the Heart of Medicine… and Nursing. We are all wounded healers in need of healing.
    Thank you for your courage and compassion.

  14. As a young nurse in a pediatric intensive care unit, I will never forget being scolded for crying after my patients died. God bless you, Lissa, for what you put up with.