We stand outside in the heat. We swat at the occasional persistent mosquito. We try to ignore the sweat beading down our foreheads and the backs of our necks. We retreat to the deepest recesses of shade we can find. We wish for a hint of a wisp of a smidgen of a breeze. We hold court on life and love. We laugh and tease and are determined to have a good time. We could be in Atlanta or Austin or Anytown, USA.
We pretend that we’re not afraid.
We are afraid, though. Our fear is legitimate: Some people hate us. And some of them are armed and dangerous.
We laughingly chat about how our mothers have implored us not to come here. We are grown women, yet we’ve each had a conversation with our mom in which she’s told us that we should stay away and stay safe.
“What if you had the flu?” my mother says pleadingly. “You wouldn’t go if you had the flu.”
“But Mom,” I say, “I don’t have the flu.” And because I don’t have the flu, I go.
We all go, even though we’d prefer to spend our afternoons almost anywhere else. We go because we think that going is important. We are standing up for what we believe.
We are volunteers at a women’s clinic. We stand, hot and miserable, between the clinic and the protestors, ushering in women who are simply trying to access health care.
“Women’s clinic” is a polite euphemism for abortion clinic. Our clinic does provide pregnancy testing, pregnancy options counseling, the morning-after pill and medical and surgical abortions, but most of the women come here specifically because they want abortions.
We believe that women should have access to reproductive health care–including abortion. Access to health care should not come with conditions and caveats and slurs and threats and danger. But it does, and this is unacceptable to us. So we stand outside in the heat and pretend that we’re not afraid.
As a woman, and as a future physician, I am passionate about health care. To me, there is no such thing as “women’s health care”; it’s all just health care. And health care should be private. It boggles my mind that “women’s health care” should be a source of debate and controversy for so many people. A woman’s health care should be discussed and thought out–and believe me, it is–but I believe that this discussion should happen between the woman and her physician. No one else. What a woman decides to do with her body is just that, a decision, and one that she should be able to make without fear of violent repercussions.
The women who come to the clinic are from all walks of life and all ethnicities. They are younger than you could imagine and older than you would think reasonable. They are accompanied by boyfriends, mothers, best friends, grandmas, husbands and aunties. Sometimes they come alone, and steely-eyed; sometimes they cry just trying to make it inside the building. But long before this moment they’ve made up their minds as to what it is they need to do. Sometimes they get mad and swear–oh boy, do they swear. They tell the protestors exactly what they think of them, in the most colorful terms possible. And when the protestors try to explain how they are “only trying to help,” the women make it clear that they don’t want or need that kind of help.
We do not engage the protestors. We don’t respond; we don’t even make eye contact. We don’t want to give them legitimacy. We don’t want to incite them to become more vocal and active. We have given up negotiating, because we’ve learned that it’s fruitless.
We try to act as though the protestors don’t exist; they do the opposite to us. They take our pictures. They photograph the patients and their license plates, if they can.
Knowing that a group of vocal and potentially violent people has your picture and knows what car you drive is terrifying. It’s the sort of fear that settles into the pit of your stomach and becomes a dull ache that you ignore. And you have to ignore it, because they already have your picture and know what you drive, so you might as well keep on going.
The protestors use religion to try to shame the patients into not entering the clinic. They recite rosaries and splash patients with what they call holy water. Sometimes they physically block patients from entering the clinic doors. They offer patients fliers full of medical inaccuracies and condemnation; if the patients refuse, fliers are thrown in their faces.
They make patients feel angry, embarrassed and afraid.
We are extremely conscious of safety and privacy–our own, and the patients’. Even when we talk among ourselves we don’t use our real names, and we ask the patients for their names in a whisper. The protestors give us nicknames based on our appearance and then catcall us. Sometimes they try polite conversation so that we feel obligated to reply, but it’s generally a ploy to engage us in more hostile conversation. So even when they’re polite, we don’t respond.
We are silently grateful each time our local law-enforcement officers circle the block. Usually, a cop or a sheriff will drive by about once per clinic shift. We don’t acknowledge them, and they don’t acknowledge us, but their presence is reassuring. The day after the Planned Parenthood shooting in Colorado Springs, a county sheriff casually sat in his car in the parking lot next to ours for hours and hours, monitoring the situation. That day, his presence was an ominous reminder of the potential for violence.
That same day, there were more protestors than usual outside the clinic, holding signs and Bibles. Those protestors broke my heart. They didn’t scare me–even though they probably should have–so much as make me unimaginably sad.
The same protestors are there every week. Most of them are white. Several are nuns. They’re all middle-aged. We do know the regulars’ names, but we never use them.
Sometimes they bus in high-school students from a local school. The students don’t really pay much attention to us or to the patients. They stand around in their plaid uniforms, teasing each other and texting, but their presence is more worrying to me than that of the regulars. It feels like a new generation is being indoctrinated.
Every week I have to convince myself to go, and every week, after I leave, I’m so glad that I went. In some small way, I feel as if I’m helping one woman at a time feel safer while getting the medical care she’s entitled to. And I wonder why this should be necessary.
About the author:
Caitlin is a member of the Saba University School of Medicine, Class of 2017. She is currently traveling across the US completing her clinical clerkships. She loves hearing people’s stories and writing about her experiences on her blog, Island Gypsy Doctor. “This story kept rattling around in my head for weeks, begging me to put pen to paper. I consider it my own silent counterprotest.”
15 thoughts on “We Pretend That We’re Not Afraid”
I’m a clinic escort in New Orleans, and I can relate to much of what you’ve written. One exception, though – it’s my husband who reminds me, every Friday, to be careful. I will admit, too, that no matter what else is happening on the sidewalk, I try to remain watchful for the vehicle that’s passed by too often, or a man sitting too long in his truck, because we all know that people attack abortion clinics.
Thank you for your beautiful heart. Be strong and never give up.
So many thank you’s for so many days.
Wonderful take on our “free” nation!
Thanks for sharing and thanks for doing this important work of trying to protect women exercising their right to make decisions about their own lives.
Caitlin, this is a truly brave and crucial thing to do. I admire you for this work, and thanks for writing about it!
Thank you for your work and your writing.
Quite simply: thank you. You are a hero!
Caitlin – I assume that the “other people” are also standing outside in the same heat you are. I understand that you are being lauded by other commentators for your work and that they appreciate it. Let me ask you – do you think that on the other side people do not appreciate what your opponents are doing? You are young physician yet – you have so much to learn about the human condition. I’m an old woman now and I am still surprised by people. You will be taking care of people you may hate. Still you will care for them with your expertise and mercy if not tenderness. Try not to be so hard on those who insist on taking religion and moral principles seriously. I guarantee that if a serious conversation could take place without assigning blame on either side we would all quite possibly be surprised by how much agreement there is on both sides of these issues, and resolve to work together.
I take religion and moral principles very seriously, and I stand with Caitlin. Are you suggesting that only those opposed to reproductive freedom can lay claim to religion and moral principles? My religion, and my moral principles, tell me that I must support women – all women – in their right to manage their own lives, their own bodies, and their own medical care.
Thank you, Jenni, for pointing out that those on the anti-choice side seem to feel that only they are on the side of religious and moral principles. When people attack women for trying to access a medical procedure, when they physically accost them and terrorize them, that is not “ethics” at work. It is merely hatred and vitriol of the degree that seems unique to those who are practicing hatred “in the name of Heaven”. I’m an old woman, too … I’ll be 70 years old in July. I have two daughters and a son, and all of them know the importance of a woman’s right to safe, private medical care.
My deepest gratitude to Caitlin and all those like her who support women in their attempt to access that care.
Thank you Caitlin, for doing this work and for writing about the experience. I have done something like this. But the stakes in your country, where providers and clinic staff have been murdered, are high. You are saving women’s lives and nurturing their spirits every time you go to help them into the clinic. Stay strong, stay well. Love and power to you. You will be an excellent doctor.
Thank goodness for people like you! It’s hard enough to get an abortion with nobody protesting. Add in screaming people holding up pictures of fetuses and it’s a nightmare, i know this good wil return to you tenfold. You are our heroes.
Harriet Squier said it right: you are brave and your work is appreciated as this matter is private, and regardless of one’s own personal opinions and any institutional stances, the patients are exercising their rights in our free and pluralistic society, and need not to be bullied or harassed; and those who stand by them at personal peril earn our admiration and respect. Thank you for writing this and for standing by these vulnerable persons.
Thank you for writing this piece. You are brave and your work is appreciated.