Pulse newmasthead 10th anniv 2252x376px

Subscribe/Energize


new subscription

Join the 11,000+ who receive Pulse weekly



energize subscription 
Stop by the
Pulse newsstand and
energize your subscription
with a contribution and
keep Pulse vibrant

Our goal this year:
500 energized subscribers

So far: 198



Joseph Fennelly ~

One morning in my office, a tall, slim package arrives along with a note, a portion of which follows:


Dr. Fennelly,

I can't apologize enough for not getting your walking stick back sooner. Since my dad's passing we have had to move my mother (who has a memory problem) several times, and with each move the walking stick moved too.



In some ways it reminded me of my dad and the relationship you and he had. It was comforting for him and us to know he had you in his corner to lean on and support him.



As you were well aware, Dad was a complicated man. He loved fiercely and struggled with his demons even more. We miss him...I miss him. But his suffering is gone and I rest in that thought....

God bless,


Maria

The writer is the daughter of my late patient Raymond, who died about eighteen months ago.

I knew Raymond well: As his primary-care doctor, I treated him for more than four decades. A tall, kind and commanding man, he was an insurance agent who cared deeply for his clients. He was also the paterfamilias of a large extended family whose members he loved and nurtured. And, yes, he was a complicated and passionate man. His particular demons were his need to be in control and his inability to recognize when he couldn't be.

Given his stubborn self-reliance, Raymond seemed like the last person to lean on anyone else--and yet, in his last illness, lean he did.

At age eighty, Raymond was diagnosed with an incurable abdominal cancer. Despite receiving excellent care from his concerned and empathetic oncologist, he insisted on coming to me to get the exact details about his prognosis, and over the next eighteen months, he visited me frequently.

Our conversations were a mix of hope, fear and frustration. Fundamentally, he wanted a blanket guarantee that he would beat this illness--but I could not and would not let myself slide into giving false reassurance.

Instead, I tried to divert him by talking about our grandchildren--he always lit up when they were mentioned. I also encouraged him to keep on umpiring high-school basketball games, which he loved, and I was glad that he followed my advice.

In the course of many such conversations throughout my career, I've learned how to offer a patient hope without making misleading or overly positive pronouncements. But Raymond, in his quest for absolute certainty, pushed me to the limits of my professional ability.



In a sense, this was simply a continuation of a dynamic that had marked our relationship for the previous forty years.

Years before, for instance, Raymond had confessed to having panic attacks while driving. After much pleading on my part, he saw a psychiatrist. This doctor helped him with appropriate medications, but kept his eyes on his computer, not on his patient. So I ended up handling the personal side of Raymond's therapy.


I faced similar struggles in getting him to face up to his diabetes, hypertension and high cholesterol. Finally, after cardiac-bypass surgery, Raymond got religion, medically speaking: He began to pay strict attention to his diet, blood pressure and cholesterol levels.

Years later, he brought this laser-sharp focus on numbers into our talks about his cancer prognosis.

Me: "What are your goals for care, Ray?"

Raymond: "I'll tell you once you tell me how long I have to live!"

Me: "I'll tell you how long you have once you tell me your goals for care!"

After a half-hour of this, I'd feel an urgent need to do something. I was practically ready to start reading tea leaves in search of a comfortingly vague prediction--anything to keep the dialogue going!

Even as I did my best to stay attuned to the depth of Raymond's despair and to maintain our rapport, I realized that his illness, combined with his therapies, was beginning to damage his nerves. His legs grew weaker, and his balance faltered: He had to place a hand against the wall just to stay upright. It was a torment to watch.

Eventually, he struggled through my office door and sat down for what I knew would be our last office visit.

What can I say? What can I do? I wondered desperately. How can I give him hope?

Suddenly I remembered my maple walking stick.

It had been a gift from another patient, Gregg, who'd carved it for me to help ease the pressure on my arthritic right knee.

Gregg would survey the forest for hours, looking for the perfect tree. Like Michelangelo visualizing David in a block of marble, he'd envision the perfect walking stick in a particular bough, then spend hours sanding and shellacking it into a work of art. The stick he'd given me was very beautiful, with prominent gnarls among its natural bends and twists. Whenever my knee became painful, the walking stick always helped.

As Raymond and I neared the end of our visit, I said, "Hold on, Ray, I've got something for you." I hurried out to my car, got the stick and brought it in to give to him.

He stared at me with an astonished smile. Then he pulled himself up and slowly walked out--leaning heavily on my walking stick.

I make it a habit to make a house call on dying patients, to console them and to better understand the family in hopes of supporting them afterward. And so, about a week later, I visited Raymond and his family.

As he lay there in bed, it was evident that he felt at peace.

"I'm not going to fight the reality any longer," he murmured faintly.

In the corner of the bedroom was the walking stick, leaning against the wall. I so wanted it back--but I didn't say anything; that would be too selfish. I had a sinking feeling that I'd never see it again.

I also felt a pang of remorse about Gregg: What if he found out that I'd given it away? How thoughtless of me.

Raymond died later that week.

Fast forward eighteen months, to the present.

Holding my beautiful walking stick once more, I study it closely. I'm struck by the profound, intimate mirroring of nature and nurture. The walking stick was once part of a tree--and, to paraphrase the poet Joyce Kilmer, all trees are poems of life. The breeze rustling through their leaves creates songs; the natural crooks, twists and gnarls of their branches reflect the crooks and twists of my arthritic joints, and of human aging.

At the end of Raymond's life, when I had few balms left with which to comfort him, I suspect that the walking stick became a symbol of support and hope for us both.

While healing is a mystery, it is also a gift. I hope that Raymond experienced the walking stick as a healing gift, and that it eased his acceptance of his illness and passing.

And I know that my gift to Raymond was also one to myself: It brought me comfort and hope at a moment when, in near despair, I felt I had nothing more to offer him.


About the author:

Joseph Fennelly is an attending physician in the department of medicine at Morristown Medical Center, NJ. He chairs the bioethics committee of the Medical Society of New Jersey and in 2015 received Lifetime Achievement awards from both the Society and Morristown Medical Center. In the mid-1970s, he was asked by Joseph and Julia Quinlan to care for Karen Ann Quinlan after the New Jersey Supreme Court gave medical decision-making to her father. "Writing not only helps me to deal with the proximity to suffering; it allows me to become both an observer and a participant in the ongoing narrative at the margins of life and death--perhaps strengthening my capacity for empathy."

Story editor:

Diane Guernsey

Comments   

# Chris Amoroso 2017-10-24 15:49
Your story is truly touching to me. It reads like poetry. I not only admire your writing I admire the life you have had and are living. You role model love, compassion, empathy, and your honest appraisal of your own imperfect humanity. I don't cry easily, in fact rarely, but I do let tears of love bathe my heart.

Thank you dear friend. Chris
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Ellen Mandel 2017-10-24 08:13
This story touched me on so many levels. The desire to offer hope in light of a serious and terminal illness is difficult. Hitting the professional wall of honesty when the patient wants a different outcome requires special powers. The walking stick in the right hands was a fine solution. I'm glad you got it back. Who knows who else may benefit from it. Thank you for your insightful narrative.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Ronna Edelstein 2017-10-22 17:08
You are an amazing physician--the mind of a scientist and the heart of a poet.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Pris Campbell 2017-10-21 17:03
What a wonderful doctor!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Nancy 2017-10-21 09:14
Thank you, Dr Fennely fir being my doctor, fir understanding the power of narrative, fir having sound and for encouraging me on my own path in narrative medicine. You are a treasure to me and many.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Joseph Fennelly 2017-10-21 12:56
thanks so much Nancy: we are all part of a large and small story- all's well that ends well? Joe
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# janice mancuso 2017-10-20 21:58
Each week the stories are captivating and evocative. Yet, sometimes, it’s a sentence or phrase in “About the Author” that prompts me to learn more. Today it was: “…the ongoing narrative at the margins of life and death.” As I’m wont to do, I googled the author. I found an almost 20-yr-old treasure in the New York Times about Dr. Fennelly—“An Old-Time Prescription: Medicine and Friendship”—htt p://www.nytimes .com/1998/01/11 /nyregion/an-ol d-time-prescrip tion-medicine-a nd-friendship.h tml. He is the real deal. I’m uplifted and energized. PS Now time to energize my subscription!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# John Harrington 2017-10-20 21:17
Wow! Such an in depth look at a doctor-patient relationship. Thank you for sharing it. Amazing how we engage and touch others when we really have no answers, and how we can gift things that we know are precious to us.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Susan Turner 2017-10-20 21:15
Thank you for sharing such a warm and caring story.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Louis Verardo, MD, 2017-10-20 20:36
What a great story, and how generous of you to share such a personal gift from one patient with another patient during his time of need. Your dying patient truly had you "to lean on" in the form of that walking stick. It is for the possibility of such close connections with patient that I remain in the practice of Medicine. Reading this entry made my week,
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# martina nicholson 2017-10-20 19:47
I love this story. I love that you found a personal way to reinforce your caring and loving, through that beautiful walking stick. And I am glad it came home again!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote